Senate rejects amendment to Bill C-234 in pivotal vote on farm carbon tax exemption

The Senate chamber (Source: Hutima, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons)

The majority of senators rejected an amended version of Bill C-234 in a pivotal vote on Tuesday, clearing the path for the proposed on-farm carbon tax exemption to move ahead for third reading and one step closer to Royal Assent.

The private member’s bill, which was introduced by Ontario MP Ben Lobb in February 2022 and approved by the House of Commons in March of this year, would remove the federal carbon levy from natural gas and propane used on farms for activities such as drying grain and heating barns and greenhouses.

Senators aligned with the Liberal government pushed an amendment through at the Senate’s agriculture and forestry committee last month, removing farm buildings from the proposed carbon price exemption.

The motion to adopt the amended version of C-234 in the Senate on Tuesday was defeated, with 42 senators voting against it and 28 in favour. Three senators that were in the chamber, including the deputy chair of the Senate ag committee, Senator Paula Simons of Alberta, abstained.

If the amended version of the bill would have been accepted in Tuesday’s vote, the revised bill would have been sent back to the House of Commons, where the government could have delayed it indefinitely.

Instead, the original version of MP Lobb’s bill is now slated for third and final reading in the Senate on Thursday.

Many individual farmers and farm groups contacted senators over the past two weeks asking them to vote against the amended bill at the report stage. More than 1,300 emails were sent to senators through an online campaign organized by the Agriculture Carbon Alliance.

“The exemptions proposed in Bill C-234 are essential to restore working capital in farmers’ hands, enabling investments in operational efficiencies,” said Grain Growers of Canada executive director Kyle Larkin, in a news release applauding the Senate’s rejection of the amendment late Tuesday. “To safeguard farmers’ profitability, sustainability and our food security, GGC urges Senators to swiftly pass this legislation at third reading. Canadian farmers have waited too long, and further delays risk withholding essential support they urgently need.”

C-234 was approved in the House of Commons earlier this year with support from all Conservative, NDP, Bloc, and Green MPs, as well as three Liberal members. An earlier version of the bill — C-206 — was also approved by the House of Commons, but died in the Senate when the 2021 federal election was called.

More to come.


Farm groups urge senators to reject any amendments to Bill C-234

Bill C-234 could be in trouble if Senate doesn’t reject its own ag committee’s amendments

Senate ag committee passes major amendment to remove buildings from on-farm carbon tax exemption bill

Bill C-234 would reduce carbon tax collected from farms by nearly a billion dollars by 2030: PBO report

Wake up with RealAgriculture

Subscribe to our daily newsletters to keep you up-to-date with our latest coverage every morning.

Wake up with RealAgriculture